If you have a sweet tooth and find yourself craving something cold and creamy, Herrell’s Ice Cream should definitely be on your radar.
Known for their rich flavors and thoughtfully crafted menu, Herrell’s Ice Cream offers a range of delightful options sure to satisfy everyone from kids to adults.
For those planning their visit or simply curious, getting familiar with the Herrell’s Ice Cream menu with prices can really help you make the perfect choice without breaking the bank.
Whether you’re stopping by for a quick treat or planning a family outing, Herrell’s offers a variety of sizes and types of ice cream along with refreshing beverages and fun extras.
Their menu isn’t just about plain scoops but also features sundaes, floats, and sampler options that let you enjoy a little bit of everything.
As you explore the Herrell’s Ice Cream menu with prices, you’ll see a balance between variety and affordability that makes it an inviting spot for all ice cream lovers.
From kiddie cups to large sundaes, the pricing reflects the quality and portion sizes, giving you options no matter your budget or appetite.
Whether it’s a simple soda or a decadent medium sundae, Herrell’s menu items are perfectly portioned and priced clearly, making your decision easy.
So get ready to browse through an easy-to-follow layout of their menu items and prices, ensuring you nab the perfect sweet treat next time you visit.
In this article, we’ll break down the Herrell’s Ice Cream menu with prices so you can see what’s available and at what cost.
Whether you’re wondering about the most popular selections or if the prices are reasonable, we’ve got you covered with detailed insights and a handy table for quick reference.
Herrell’s Ice Cream Menu With Prices
Cone Or Dish
| Cone Or Dish | $1.20+ | ||
| extras, hot fudge-1:00,whipped cream-.90,candy, nuts-.60,fruit-.80 | |||
Smoosh — Ins
| Goodies Smooshed-In | $3.95+ | |
| Goodies Smooshed–In (Lg. Only) | $5.65 | |
| Goodies Smooshed-In | $4.55+ | |
Goodie Selection
| blueberries, butterfinger, butterscotch chips, chocolate chips, chocolate covered raisins, chocolate sprinkles, health bar, hershey bar, kit-kat, m&m’s, mini-m&m’s, nestle’s crunch, hydrox cookies, peanuts, peanut butter chips, peanut m&m’s pecans, pistachios, rainbow sprinkles, raspberries, reese’s peanut butter cups, reese’s pieces, roasted almonds, strawberries, shredded coconut, toasted coconut, walnuts |
Sundaes
| Sundaes | $2.96+ | |
| sundaes are made with any available flavor of herrell’s own, rich, creamy ice cream, or frozen yogurt. then choose: herrell’s homemade hot fudge (sometimes we have special flavors of it ) herrell’s homemade butterscotch, herrell’s homemade caramel, peanut butter sauce (yummy!), strawberry, raspberry, or blueberry topping add your choice of nuts or candy (see goodies selections above) top that off with your choice of: homemade whipped cream, homemade chocolate whipped cream (our whipped creams are not from a can!) marshmallow topping and finally, a classical cherry on top! |
Specialty Items
| The Great Brownie Sundae a regular sundae built on top of a scrumptious frosted brownie with walnuts! | $5.95 | |
| Quadruple Chocolate Sundae a large sundae with herrell’s chocolate pudding ice cream, our hot fudge, real chocolate whipped cream, and m & m’s or anything else chocolate you see! (also available in medium size, $4.40) | $5.65 | |
| Banana Split the ultimate ice cream feast! made with strictly your own choices of herrell’s fabulous ice creams and toppings! | $5.95+ | |
| Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Pie we bake it fresh right here! | $1.45 | |
| Ala Mode add 2.40 to any cake, hot pie, or brownie and make it ala mode with a scoop of ice cream, any flovor. often we have our own ice cream sandwiches, double-dipped chocolate bananas, and other novelties! | – | |
Milkshakes & Floats
| Small Milkshakes | $3.25 | |
| Orange Milkshake | $3.85 | |
| Large Milkshakes | $3.85 | |
| Double-Thick Shake | $0.60 | |
| Milkshake Float | $4.70 | |
| Malted Milkshake | $0.25 | |
| Add Candy For | $0.30 | |
| Add Fruit For | $0.50 | |
| Ice Cream Soda made with chocolate, vanilla, strawberry or coffee syrup and the ice cream flavor of your choice! | $3.85 | |
| Floats made with root beer, pepsi, orange or lemon-lime soda, and the ice cream flavor of your choice! | $3.85 | |
| Spritzers made with sorbet or sherbet and juice, lemonade, or soda, and spun on the milkshake mixer! | $3.85 | |
| Other Assorted Beverages hot chocolate with whipped cream, lemonade, cider, hot and cold teas, orange juice, mango juice, spring water, natural bottled sodas, pepsi, diet pepsi, orange slice, root beer, and lemon– lime soda | – | |
Flavors
| Ice Cream | |
| almond butter, almond caramel swirl, almond cream, amaretto, baker’s choice, banana, banana daiquiri, black raspberry, black raspberry chocolate chip, blueberry, brown cow, burnt sugar ‘n’ butter, butter almond heath, butter pecan, butternut, cafe au lait, cafe ‘l’ orange, cappuccino, caramel custard, carob, cashew butter, chai, cheesecake blueberry swirl, cheesecake cream, cheesecake strawberry swirl, cherry pie ala mode, chimp chunk, chocolate, chocolate banana, chocolate bourbon pecan, chocolate chaos, chocolate cherry, chocolate chip, chocolate chocolate chip, chocolate hazelnut, chocolate peanut butter, chocolate peppermint, chocolate pudding, cinnamon nutmeg, cocoacoconut, coconut, coffee, coffee hazelnut cr | |
| Ice Cream | |
| almond butter, almond butter, almond caramel swirl, almond cream, amaretto, baker’s choice, banana, banana daiquiri, black raspberry, black raspberry chocolate chip, blueberry, brown cow, burnt sugar ‘n’ butter | |
| Ice Cream | |
| covered coffee beans, everything, french chocolate, french vanilla, ginger, girlsenberry, grape nut raisin, Halloween bash, hazelnut cream, heats and flowers heath bar crunch, jalapeno, Kentucky bourbon vanilla, key lime cardamom, key lime cream, lemon custard, lemon custard fudge swirl, lemon mousse, malted chocolate, malted vanilla, mango, maple cream, maple walnut, Mexican chocolate, microchip, milk chocolate, mint chocolate chip, mint cookies ‘n’ cream, mocha, mocha heath, mocha roasted almond, mochaccino, more cookies than cream,mudpie, negative chocolate chip, ooey-gooey, orange creams cal, Oregon cherry vanilla, peanut butter, peanut butter mud pie, pecan cinnamon caramel swirl, peppermint, peppermint stick, piano colada& |
| Sherbet And Sorbet | |
| orange sherbet, raspberry sherbet, blueberry sorbet, cider sorbet, cranberry-apple sorbet, lemon sorbet, lime sorbet, mango sorbet, orange-strawberry sorbet, pink grapefruit sorbet, raspberry sorbet. | |
| Frozen Yogurt | |
| banana, black raspberry, cappuccino, citrus-peach, coconut, cookies’n’ cream, dutch chocolate, egg nog, espresso, hazelnut, holiday spice, honey almond, lemon, malted vanilla, maple vanilla, mocha, orange creamsicle, peachtree, peanut butter, pumpkin, strawberry, vanilla | |
| Frozen Yogurt (No Sugar Added/ Non-Fat) | |
| dutch chocolate, espresso, orange creamsicle, vanilla. | |
| No-moo (Non-Dairy) | |
| chocolate no-moo, peanut butter no-moo. | |
| Herrell’s Hot Fudge Flavors | |
| original, peppermint, almond, orange. |
Most Popular Items
Among Herrell’s Ice Cream offerings, some items consistently stand out as favorites among customers.
The variety of ice cream sizes allows visitors to enjoy just the right amount, whether it’s a quick kiddie portion or a large scoop for sharing.
The Medium Ice Cream ($5.99) is often a go-to for adults wanting a generous serving without feeling too indulgent.
Meanwhile, the Large Sundae ($10.05) is a popular choice for those craving a decadent dessert topped with syrups, nuts, or fresh fruit.
The Hand Packed Pint ($8.90) or Quart ($12.30) are excellent options for those looking to take Herrell’s flavors home.
These pre-packed sizes preserve the creamy texture and bold flavors so you can enjoy the treat long after your visit.
Additionally, the Floats ($9.50) make for a refreshing twist combining soda and ice cream, perfect on a sunny day or for anyone who loves a fizzy dessert.
The Sampler ($9.50) also deserves a mention, especially for customers who like to try multiple flavors in one sitting.
This option lets you enjoy a variety without committing to a single flavor. For the younger crowd, the Kiddie Ice Cream ($3.50) and Kiddie Sundae ($5.50) provide appropriately sized treats that are easy on the wallet and just the right amount of sweetness.
Is Herrell’s Ice Cream Expensive?
When considering the price, Herrell’s Ice Cream is fairly reasonable given the quality of ingredients, portion sizes, and the overall experience.
Prices range from kid-friendly options starting at $3.50 to premium sundaes and pints topping out around $12 or so.
In comparison to other ice cream shops and premium dessert spots, these prices are competitive and represent good value for fresh, hand-packed, and delicious ice cream.
A price around $6 for a medium scoop is typical for artisan ice cream brands. The sundaes and floats, priced between $8.50 and $10, are also consistent with what you’d expect from a higher-end ice cream parlor, especially one that uses quality ingredients and unique flavors.
Additionally, the option to take pints and quarts home for under $13 offers a convenience factor that can be economical for families or groups.
Overall, Herrell’s balances quality and price well, providing both everyday treats and indulgent dessert experiences.
Whether you want something simple like a small scoop or a special occasion sundae, you’re likely to find a price point that works for you.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
What sizes of ice cream does Herrell’s offer?
Herrell’s menu includes several ice cream sizes: Kiddie, Small, Medium, and Large portions, allowing customers to select the right amount for their appetite.
Can I purchase ice cream to take home?
Yes, Herrell’s offers Hand Packed Pints and Quarts, which are perfect for enjoying your favorite flavors at home.
Are there options for children on the menu?
Absolutely, the Kiddie Ice Cream and Kiddie Sundae are specifically made for younger guests with appropriate portion sizes and prices.
Does Herrell’s sell beverages?
Yes, you can buy Canned Sodas priced at $2.75 as a refreshing companion to your ice cream.
What is the Sampler offering?
The Sampler is a menu item that lets you try multiple flavors or styles of ice cream in one serving, perfect for indecisive or experimental eaters.
Are floats available on the menu?
Yes, floats are offered at $9.50 and combine soda with ice cream for a fizzy dessert experience.
Is the pricing consistent across all locations?
Prices may vary slightly by location, so it’s a good idea to check with your nearest Herrell’s Ice Cream outlet for the most accurate pricing.
Conclusion
Herrell’s Ice Cream provides a delicious and diverse menu that caters to all tastes and budgets.
With clear pricing and options ranging from kiddie treats to indulgent sundaes and take-home pints, you’ll find something that hits the sweet spot every time.
The quality of their ice cream combined with reasonable pricing makes it a sweet destination worth visiting again and again.
Whether you’re craving a quick scoop, planning a family outing, or picking up a quart to enjoy at home, Herrell’s offers options that delight every ice cream lover.
Note: Prices may vary slightly by location. Always check with your nearest outlet for exact pricing.
Explore More
- Blake’s Lotaburger Menu With Prices
- La Michoacana Menu With Prices
- Cheeburger Cheeburger Menu With Prices
- Yogurtland Menu With Prices
- Wawa Menu With Prices